The Carolina Panthers suffered a disappointing 17-7 defeat against the New Orleans Saints on November 9, 2025, a result that raises significant questions about quarterback Bryce Young. Entering the game with a record of 5-4, the Panthers faced a struggling Saints team that had managed only one victory all season. Despite the favorable matchup, the Panthers’ offense faltered, and Young’s performance drew particular scrutiny.
In a game that showcased the Saints’ commitment to shutting down the Panthers’ rushing attack, they effectively neutralized running back Rico Dowdle. Young was forced to take charge in the passing game but could only muster a mere 130 total yards, culminating in a damaging interception in the fourth quarter. This lack of production has intensified discussions about Young’s viability as the franchise quarterback, especially as he enters his third NFL season.
Struggles Persist for Young and the Panthers
Young’s trajectory since being selected first overall in the 2023 NFL Draft has been fraught with challenges. The Panthers’ roster was in disarray during his rookie campaign, highlighted by the midseason trade of star running back Christian McCaffrey and the departure of top receiver DJ Moore to the Chicago Bears. With a receiving corps led by 33-year-old Adam Thielen and journeyman DJ Chark, Young faced an uphill battle. His statistics reflected those challenges; he finished his rookie year with 11 touchdowns against 10 interceptions and a completion rate below 60%.
Recognizing the need for improvement, the Panthers made significant changes in their coaching staff and roster. The hiring of offensive coordinator Dave Canales, known for revitalizing quarterback Baker Mayfield in Tampa Bay, marked a pivotal shift. The Panthers also invested in their receiving corps, drafting wide receivers Xavier Legette and Tetairoa McMillan in consecutive first rounds, aiming to provide Young with the support he lacked.
Despite these efforts, Young’s performance has not shown the expected progression. His second season began poorly, leading to a brief benching in favor of veteran Andy Dalton. Although Young displayed some improvement later in the year, the current season has seen him struggle once more. In nine starts, he has surpassed 200 passing yards only once and ranks 38th in the NFL with a passer rating of 79.7.
Future Uncertain for the Panthers
The Panthers invested heavily to acquire Young, raising expectations for his development. However, after 41 starts, the evidence suggests he may be closer to a backup quarterback role than that of a franchise leader. With the team now at a 5-5 record, the Panthers will need to evaluate their options moving forward.
As the season progresses, the pressure mounts on Young to demonstrate that he can rise to the occasion. The organization faces difficult decisions regarding his future, weighing the potential for growth against the reality of his on-field performance. With each passing game, the spotlight on Young intensifies, and the Panthers’ playoff aspirations hang in the balance.
