The finale of Season 34 of *Dancing With the Stars* ignited a lively response from the audience as judge Carrie Ann Inaba faced backlash for her critique of frontrunner Robert Irwin‘s performance. Irwin, partnered with professional dancer Witney Carson, opened the evening with a spirited quickstep to Jet’s “Are You Gonna Be My Girl,” which initially received enthusiastic applause from the audience.
As the performance concluded, the judges expressed their admiration, but Inaba’s subsequent comments took a turn. She described the routine as “amazing” and “wonderful,” yet the crowd quickly sensed a critique was forthcoming. When she began her next sentence with, “There was a bit of a,” the audience responded with loud boos, clearly displeased with the impending criticism.
Inaba attempted to ease the tension by laughing nervously and clarifying her intent. “I don’t want to give it to anybody who doesn’t absolutely deserve it,” she stated, attempting to maintain her position of honesty in judging. She reassured the audience that her critique did not diminish Irwin and Carson’s potential as strong contenders for the coveted mirrorball trophy.
The reaction from the crowd was so intense that host Alfonso Ribeiro had to shift to a skybox, where Irwin and Carson spoke with former contestant Julianne Hough. Unfortunately, Inaba’s comments were lost to the audience’s discontent, and the judges ultimately awarded Irwin and Carson a near-perfect score of 29, with Inaba’s score of 9 being the only one that fell short.
During their conversation with Hough, Robert Irwin reflected on his journey, expressing gratitude towards Carson for her unwavering belief in him. He also shared heartfelt sentiments about his family, particularly his mother and sister, whom he described as “the most important” and strongest influences in his life.
This dramatic moment from the *Dancing With the Stars* finale showcased not only the pressures of competition but also the emotional stakes involved as contestants seek validation and success on a national stage. The episode aired on March 15, 2024, thrilling audiences with its blend of talent and unexpected drama.
