Kalani Sitake has decided to remain as head coach of Brigham Young University (BYU) after engaging in discussions with Penn State regarding their head coaching vacancy. According to reports from ESPN, Sitake has reached an agreement on a lucrative extension with BYU, affirming his commitment to the program he has led for the past decade.
The decision comes as Penn State expressed significant interest in Sitake, positioning him as a primary candidate for their coaching search. While negotiations were underway, KSL.com confirmed that a new deal was being finalized, although it had not been officially signed as of early December 2, 2025. Despite this, Sitake has reportedly informed various parties, including Penn State officials, of his intention to stay in Provo.
In an effort to retain Sitake, BYU is enhancing its commitment, which will reportedly include increased support for his coaching staff. This encompasses significant investments for assistants such as offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick and defensive coordinator Jay Hill, as well as initiatives focused on name, image, and likeness (NIL) opportunities for players.
The question now arises: is this investment justified? According to BYU defensive back Evan Johnson, the answer is clear. Following a 41-21 victory over UCF, Johnson proclaimed, “Yes, yes, yes; he’s the best coach in the nation. That’s all I’ve got to say.”
Financial backing for the BYU program comes from notable donors, including Min Kim, CEO of Nutricost; Jason McGowan, CEO of Crumbl; and King Husein, CEO of Span Construction and Engineering. Their support has been pivotal in ensuring the program remains competitive and attractive for top coaching talent.
Under Sitake’s leadership, BYU has recorded an impressive overall record of 83-44 over the last ten seasons. This includes a remarkable 11-1 showing in the 2025 season and an 8-1 performance in Big 12 play. The program has also made seven bowl appearances, achieving a 4-3 postseason record during his tenure.
Sitake’s success is further underscored by his winning percentage of 56-19 since 2020, placing him seventh among active coaches in the Football Bowl Subdivision. Only programs like Georgia, Ohio State, Alabama, Oregon, Notre Dame, and Michigan have a higher winning percentage during this period.
As the Cougars prepare for the Big 12 championship game against No. 5 Texas Tech, the stability provided by Sitake’s new contract could prove vital in maintaining momentum for the program. The upcoming match presents an opportunity for BYU to showcase their strength in a critical game, further solidifying Sitake’s status as a pivotal figure in college football.
With Sitake’s decision to stay at BYU, the program can continue to build on its recent successes and foster a competitive environment, ensuring that the Cougars remain a force in the college football landscape.
