Myles Garrett made history on January 4, 2024, by setting a new NFL single-season sack record with his 23rd sack. This achievement has sparked significant interest among sports card collectors, leading to a remarkable surge in the value of Garrett’s trading cards. Many collectors view this moment as a prime opportunity to capitalize on heightened demand.
One of Garrett’s most coveted rookie cards, the 2017 Panini Prizm Gold, which is limited to only ten copies, was sold on Sunday night for $3,600. This marked a dramatic increase from its previous sale price of $1,725 in May. Such price fluctuations indicate the potential profitability for collectors looking to sell while interest is at its peak.
The trend in Garrett’s card values is not confined to high-end collectibles. For instance, the 2017 Panini Donruss Optic Holo PSA 10, which could be purchased for only $82 in October, saw a staggering increase, selling for $400 on Sunday. This represents a remarkable 400 percent rise in value, prompting collectors to ponder the sustainability of such pricing.
Historically, defensive players like Garrett have faced challenges in maintaining their card values over time. For context, the highest recorded sale of a J.J. Watt card is below $6,000, while wide receiver Justin Jefferson has seen his card exceed $80,000. This data suggests a cautious approach for those considering investments in Garrett’s cards.
Yet, the enthusiasm surrounding the Cleveland Browns community cannot be overlooked. The city has a passionate fan base that may encourage collectors to hold onto Garrett’s cards as a testament to his remarkable achievements. The emotional connection to a player can sometimes defy market trends, making this a unique situation.
Ultimately, the dynamic of supply and demand will dictate the future of Garrett’s card market. As collectors weigh the potential for continued growth against historical trends, the allure of owning a piece of NFL history remains strong. Whether they choose to buy or sell, the impact of Garrett’s record-setting season will undoubtedly resonate within the hobby for years to come.
