URGENT UPDATE: The Diocese of Brooklyn has announced plans to settle approximately 1,100 remaining sexual abuse lawsuits and provide compensation to survivors. Brooklyn Bishop Robert Brennan confirmed this significant decision on Thursday, following a similar announcement from the Archdiocese of New York late last year.
This move comes as part of the Diocese’s effort to mitigate the emotional strain on victim-survivors by avoiding prolonged court battles. In a letter, Brennan stated that discussions are underway with attorneys representing hundreds of survivors to expedite this process. “The Diocese and our legal counsel have spoken with attorneys representing hundreds of victim-survivors to begin this process,” he wrote.
Survivors’ attorneys are reacting to this announcement with mixed feelings. Attorney Jeff Anderson, representing over 200 survivors, described the Bishop’s update as “positive news,” acknowledging the long struggle survivors have faced. “For over six years, the Diocese has denied responsibility, contested virtually every case, causing survivors to endure, not just delay, but additional harm,” Anderson said.
However, not all legal representatives are convinced. Attorney Anelga Doumanian, who represents 50 survivors, dismissed the bishop’s letter as “nothing short of a PR stunt masquerading as a settlement offer.” Doumanian criticized the Diocese for failing to communicate with survivors or their legal teams regarding a comprehensive settlement. “This is a pseudo-offer at best, and survivors won’t be fooled,” she asserted.
The Diocese has previously settled claims exceeding $100 million for more than 500 accusers since launching its Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program in 2017. Brennan emphasized that funds for these settlements arise from monetizing existing assets, not from donations or the closure of Catholic schools.
As this global resolution process unfolds, the Diocese continues to express concern for the healing of victim-survivors and their families. “May the Lord our God bring healing and peace,” Brennan wrote.
It is crucial to monitor how these developments unfold, as the Diocese faces scrutiny regarding its commitment to justice for survivors after years of legal resistance. The implications of this settlement could reshape the landscape for survivors of abuse and impact the broader conversation around accountability within religious institutions.
Stay tuned for more updates as this story develops.
