UPDATE: In a stunning upset, the Ohio State Buckeyes fell to the Indiana Hoosiers with a score of 13-10 at Lucas Oil Stadium on December 6, 2025. The loss raises urgent questions about the Buckeyes’ offensive strategy, particularly their failure to utilize deep passing plays.
Despite entering the game with high expectations, quarterback Julian Sayin, who ranked first nationally in completion percentage for deep throws, managed only a handful of attempts downfield. Ohio State’s offensive struggles were evident as they recorded just three passes that traveled over 15 yards throughout the game, leaving fans and analysts alike baffled.
As the Buckeyes faced an undefeated season on the line, the team allowed five sacks and failed to capitalize on Indiana’s defensive weaknesses, particularly their single deep safety coverage. The Hoosiers effectively exploited this gap, with Indiana quarterback Fernando Mendoza throwing a decisive 33-yard completion to Charlie Becker that sealed the game.
Critics have pointed to head coach Ryan Day’s conservative play-calling as a significant factor in the loss. Since taking the helm in 2019, Ohio State has consistently ranked poorly in deep pass attempts, with this season seeing them at an alarming 127th in the FBS for deep throws. This trend of underutilizing talented players like Jeremiah Smith and Carnell Tate has frustrated fans who expect explosive plays from the Buckeyes’ offense.
Coach Day’s strategy appeared especially misguided as the Buckeyes played from behind in the second half. The team continued to rely on outdated formations, including heavy use of the I-formation and multiple tight ends, rather than adjusting to Indiana’s defensive setup.
In a post-game statement, Indiana coach Curt Cignetti acknowledged Ohio State’s potential, stating, “They’re super explosive, capable of scoring from anywhere on the field at any time.” However, it seems that capability was not harnessed effectively on Saturday.
As the Buckeyes reflect on this disappointing defeat, fans are left wondering what adjustments will be made moving forward. With critical games ahead, the urgency for Ohio State to reassess their offensive approach has never been more pressing. Stay tuned for further developments as this story unfolds.
